As soon as I shared the February Bucket List, I got a handful of messages asking for the Air Fryer Bagel Recipe. I have been working on it all month and I finally nailed it! Before you think to yourself, there is no way I can make bagels, stop. These are SO freakin easy y’all and they are SO good! You could easily throw these together on a Saturday morning for the whole fam!
The other thing I love about these is you can make em your own! Add your favorite toppings and you’re good to go! For this round, I did Plain, Everything, Cheddar Cheese, Chocolate Chip and French Toast. (Scroll down for deets on those!)
2 cups all-purpose flour
1tbs baking powder
1tp kosher salt
2 cups Greek Yogurt, PLAIN
1 egg, beaten
Toppings of choice
Whisk dry ingredients together in bowl. Mix in Greek Yogurt with wooden spoon.
Note about the Greek Yogurt: Be sure to use the thick part of the yogurt and not the liquid-y part. It will mess with the consistency of your bagels.
Mix until combined then dump onto floured surface. Quickly knead it into a ball (not too much). Cut dough into 8 equal pieces then roll into long tubes – like 10″ long. Connect the ends to form a bagel shape then brush with beaten egg. Finish with your favorite toppings.
Place in preheated air fryer at 350 for 11-12 minutes until golden brown. Remove to wire rack and let cool then enjoy!
PS: If you have the same air fryer as me, I cooked these two at a time on the middle rack and removed the top rack from the air fryer.
Everything Bagel – I just sprinkled Trader Joe’s Everything But The Bagel seasoning on top!
Cheddar Cheese Bagel – I just sprinkled shredded cheddar on top
French Toast Bagel – I sprinkled brown sugar and cinnamon on top and a small drizzle of maple syrup.
Chocolate Chip Bagel – I placed chocolate chips on top but in the future, I would mix it in the dough instead.
Some Bagel Variations I Will Be Trying Out:
So there you have it, Air Fryer Bagels! I hope you guys love this one and add it to your list of Air Fryer Recipes! I think its a winner for sure!
PS: Subscribe to the blog HERE so you never miss a post!